At your location in just 29 minutesGet the measurements right away.T&C

Comparison · Balconies & Terraces

Invisible Grill vs Pigeon Net vs Normal Grill: Which One Does Your Balcony Need?

Invisible grill vs pigeon net vs iron grill, compared honestly: which stops birds, which is a fall barrier, upkeep, view, and when you need two layers.

By the Fabrockers teamPublished 13 min read
Neighbouring balconies fitted with vertical steel cables and a pigeon net
In this guide
  1. Invisible grill vs pigeon net: the short answer
  2. What an invisible grill, a pigeon net and a normal grill actually are
  3. Invisible grill vs pigeon net vs iron grill: the three-way comparison
  4. Invisible grill or pigeon net: which is better for your balcony
  5. Invisible grill vs normal iron grill: view against strength
  6. Invisible grill vs mesh: two products that barely overlap
  7. The glass route: a railing or sliding glass instead of a grill or a net
  8. Using a pigeon net and a grill together
  9. Questions to ask an invisible grill fitter before you pay
  10. How to decide between a net, a mesh and a grill in four steps
  11. What moves the cost of a net, a mesh or a grill

Key takeaways

  • They do different jobs. A pigeon net is for birds. A grill, invisible or iron, is for people.
  • A pigeon net is never a fall barrier. It will not hold a child or an adult, however tight it looks.
  • An invisible grill keeps the view; an iron grill is the stronger, older answer. Both depend on how well they are fixed.
  • Many homes need two layers. A grill for safety, and a net or mesh behind it for pigeons.
  • We fit nets, mesh and glass, not grills. Where a grill is the right answer, we say so and step back.

Invisible grill vs pigeon net: the short answer

People compare these two because both close the open side of a balcony and both keep the view. They are not the same kind of product. A pigeon net keeps birds out; an invisible grill is meant to keep people in. Choose by which of those two jobs you need done.

If your only problem is pigeons, a net does it for much less money. If you worry about a fall, a net is the wrong product and a grill is the right one. If you have both worries, you will probably need both layers. The normal iron grill is the third choice, and it is still the most common safety barrier in Indian flats.

One thing first. We fit pigeon nets, balcony mesh and balcony glass. We do not fit invisible grills or iron grills. This guide describes them fairly, because an honest comparison is more use to you than a sales page.

Two neighbouring apartment balconies seen from outside, one with a thin pigeon net and one with vertical invisible grill cables
From a distance both nearly disappear. Up close they are built for completely different jobs.

What an invisible grill, a pigeon net and a normal grill actually are

The invisible grill: tensioned steel cables

An invisible grill is a row of thin stainless steel cables pulled tight between two tracks. One track is fixed at the top of the opening and one at the bottom. The cables usually run vertically, a few centimetres apart, and often carry a clear nylon coating. From inside the room you see thin lines. From across the road you see almost nothing. The spacing and the cable size vary from one fitter to the next, so ask for both in writing.

The pigeon net: knotted nylon on hooks

A pigeon net is a nylon net, knotted at every crossing so a torn strand does not run. It hangs on steel hooks drilled into the wall and ceiling. A border rope through its edge is pulled tight, so no corner sags. It is light and thin, and it comes down without leaving much of a mark. It is a bird net and nothing else.

The normal grill: welded iron or steel bars

A normal grill is made of mild steel bars or flats, welded into a frame and fixed into the wall. People call it an iron grill or an MS grill. It is heavy, strong and plainly visible. It needs paint to keep rust away. A local fabricator makes it to the opening and a welder or mason fixes it.

Close view of clear coated stainless steel cables fixed into an aluminium bottom track on a balcony ledge
An invisible grill is only as good as its tracks, its anchors and the tension in each cable.

Invisible grill vs pigeon net vs iron grill: the three-way comparison

Invisible grill, pigeon net and iron grill compared
What mattersPigeon netInvisible grillIron grill
Main jobKeeps birds outFall barrier that keeps the viewFall barrier and security against entry
Fall protectionNone. Never rely on itBuilt for it; depends on cable, spacing and fixingBuilt for it; depends on bar size and fixing
Stops pigeonsYesOften not; depends on the cable spacingNo; birds pass between the bars
Stops mosquitoesNoNoNo
View and lightNearly clearNearly clearClearly blocked
Rust and upkeepNo rust; sun ages the nylon over yearsGood steel resists rust; tension needs checkingNeeds repainting; rusts at joints if neglected
Security against break-inNoneLimited; cables can be cutStrong
Way out in an emergencyCut with scissors or a knifeAsk the fitter how cables are released or cutNeeds an openable panel, or it blocks the exit
Cost levelLowest of the threeUsually the highestIn between; depends on design and weight
Who fits itWe do, in BengaluruA specialist; not our tradeA fabricator; not our trade

Read the second row twice. The words depends on are doing real work there. A grill of either kind is only a safety barrier if it is anchored into sound structure and made to a proper size. That is checked on site, by the person who fixes it.

Invisible grill or pigeon net: which is better for your balcony

Start from who and what uses the balcony. Three common cases cover most homes.

  • Only pigeons bother you, and no small child lives in the flat. A pigeon net is the sensible choice. It costs least and it solves the whole problem. See pigeon net installation.
  • A small child or a pet uses the balcony. A grill comes first. Whether it is invisible or iron is your choice and your society's. Add a net or mesh later if birds are a problem.
  • You want pigeons and mosquitoes gone together. Neither a net nor a grill does that. Stainless steel mesh in frames does. See balcony mosquito mesh.

People often hope an invisible grill will stop pigeons too. Sometimes it does, when the cables are close together. Often it does not. A pigeon can squeeze through a gap that looks too small for it, and it can perch on the bottom track. If birds are part of the reason you are buying, ask the fitter directly and plan for a net behind the cables.

Invisible grill vs normal iron grill: view against strength

This is a choice between two real safety barriers, so it deserves care. Neither is our trade. Here is how the two usually compare.

The iron grill is the stronger and simpler product. Thick welded bars resist a push, a climb and a break-in. Its weak points are rust, weight and looks. It blocks the view, darkens the room a little and needs repainting every few years. Some newer societies do not allow one on the outside face, or allow only one pattern.

The invisible grill wins on view and light. Good stainless steel does not need paint. Its weak points are less obvious. Everything depends on the anchors, the tracks and the tension. Cables can slacken over time and need tightening. Quality varies a lot between fitters, and a poor one looks the same as a good one on day one.

  • For security against entry on a low floor, an iron grill is the stronger choice.
  • For a high floor with a view you want to keep, an invisible grill is the usual choice.
  • For a society with facade rules, ask first. The rule often decides it for you.

Invisible grill vs mesh: two products that barely overlap

Mesh here means mosquito mesh: a fine woven screen in slim aluminium frames across the balcony opening. It keeps out mosquitoes, flies and lizards. In stainless steel, it also keeps out pigeons.

An invisible grill does none of that. Its gaps are far wider than any insect. In return, mesh does nothing an invisible grill does. Mesh is insect screening, not a fall barrier. It will not reliably hold a child who leans or climbs on it.

So the two work well together. The grill goes on the outside line as the safety layer. The mesh frames fit inside it. If you already have a grill of either kind, mesh mounts to it or just behind it without trouble. For the doorway only, a pleated mosquito net keeps the room clear and leaves the balcony open. The mosquito mesh types page compares the systems.

A balcony with an old painted iron grill outside and slim framed mosquito mesh panels fitted just inside it
Two layers, two jobs. The grill is the barrier; the mesh behind it stops insects and birds.

The glass route: a railing or sliding glass instead of a grill or a net

There is a fourth route that the usual comparison leaves out. Glass can do part of each job.

A glass railing is a railing in thick toughened glass, held in steel clamps, posts or a base channel. It has no gaps to slip through and no bars to climb. It is a railing, though, so it stops at railing height. The space above it stays open. We build new balcony glass railings in Bengaluru and across Delhi NCR.

A sliding glass enclosure closes the open side above the railing with toughened glass in aluminium frames. Closed, it keeps out pigeons, rain and most dust. Open, the balcony is open again, to birds as well. It is a weather cover first. We fit balcony glass enclosures in Bengaluru and across Delhi NCR. Our balcony cover ideas guide compares every cover by the problem it solves.

A frameless toughened glass balcony railing on steel clamps with an open view above it on a high floor
A glass railing has no gaps and no bars, but it stops at railing height. The space above stays open.

If you have a glass railing that shakes or has rusting clamps, fix that before adding anything. See glass railing shaking. We repair railings in Bengaluru and across Delhi NCR.

Using a pigeon net and a grill together

This is a common finished balcony in a family flat, and it works well. The grill is the safety layer. The net keeps birds from nesting between the bars and on the ledge.

  • Fit the grill first. The net is then fixed onto or just inside the grill.
  • Keep the net on its own hooks where possible. Hooks into the wall and slab hold tension better than ties around bars.
  • Leave the grill's opening section usable. The net should not tie an emergency exit shut. Ask for that part of the net to open.
  • Net the AC ledge too. Birds that lose the balcony often move to the outdoor unit. See pigeons sitting on the AC outdoor unit.
Close-up of a taut balcony pigeon net border rope threaded through steel ceiling hooks, viewed safely from inside the balcony
The border rope and perimeter hooks should hold the net neatly against the opening.

A net goes up only on an empty opening. We do not remove birds, eggs or nests. If there is a nest, wait until the chicks have gone. The page on a pigeon nest in the balcony explains the order.

Questions to ask an invisible grill fitter before you pay

We do not fit invisible grills, so we have nothing to sell you here. These are the questions we would ask if it were our own balcony.

  1. What grade of steel are the cables, and are they coated? Ask for it in writing on the quotation.
  2. What is the gap between cables? Ask what gap the fitter uses where small children live.
  3. What are the tracks fixed into? Anchors must go into the slab or a sound wall, never into loose plaster or a thin parapet.
  4. How is each cable tensioned, and who re-tightens it later? Ask whether that visit is included.
  5. How do adults get out in an emergency? Ask to be shown, not told.
  6. Has the society approved it? Get the answer before you pay an advance.

How to decide between a net, a mesh and a grill in four steps

  1. Name the jobBirds, insects or people. Write down which one you are solving. Most confusion ends at this step.
  2. Put safety first if a child is involvedA grill or a checked railing is the first layer. A net or mesh is only ever the second.
  3. Check the society ruleAsk what is allowed on the outside face. Nets and mesh usually pass easily. Grills and glass often need approval.
  4. Call the right tradeA grill fitter for a grill. Us for a net, a mesh, a glass railing or balcony glass. Ask each for a written quote after a site visit.

Book a visit. We measure the opening, show the net and mesh samples, and quote in writing. Pigeon nets are fitted in Bengaluru.

What moves the cost of a net, a mesh or a grill

A pigeon net is the lowest-cost of all of these, because nylon and hooks are light materials. Its price follows the area of the open face. Framed steel mesh costs more per square foot than a net. An iron grill is priced by its weight and design. An invisible grill usually costs the most, and its price follows the area, the cable spacing and the steel grade.

We print no figures in guides. The current starting rates for nets and mesh are on their service pages, and the mosquito net price guide compares the mesh types. For a grill, ask two fitters for written quotes with the same cable or bar size, so you compare like with like.

Common questions

Which is better, an invisible grill or a pigeon net?

Neither is better, because they do different jobs. A pigeon net keeps birds out and costs far less. An invisible grill is a fall barrier that keeps the view. If you need both jobs done, you need both layers.

Can pigeons get through an invisible grill?

Often, yes. It depends on the gap between the cables, and pigeons squeeze through smaller gaps than most people expect. They can also perch on the bottom track. If birds are a problem, plan a pigeon net or steel mesh behind the cables.

Is an invisible grill as strong as an iron grill?

A welded iron grill is generally the stronger product, especially against a break-in. An invisible grill can be a sound fall barrier when the steel, the spacing and the anchors are right. Its strength depends much more on the quality of the fitting, so check that carefully.

Can a pigeon net be fitted over an existing grill?

Yes, and it is very common. The net is fixed onto the grill or just inside it, on its own hooks where possible. The grill stays the safety layer, and the net stops birds nesting between the bars.

Does Fabrockers install invisible grills or iron grills?

No. Grills of both kinds are another trade's work. We fit pigeon nets in Bengaluru, and glass railings, sliding balcony glass and balcony mosquito mesh in Bengaluru, Mumbai, Pune and Delhi NCR. Where a grill is the right answer, we say so.

Is an invisible grill or a mesh better against mosquitoes?

Only mesh works against mosquitoes. The gaps in an invisible grill are far too wide to stop any insect. Mesh is not a fall barrier, though, so in a home with small children the grill comes first and the mesh fits behind it.

Have a question this guide did not answer? Call us or send a photo on WhatsApp and we will tell you what it needs.

Chat on WhatsApp